Magic Speed 5 vs Deviate Nitro 4

The Magic Speed 5 is Asics doing the sensible thing: a carbon-plated running shoe that hands you race-day pop without asking for full super-shoe money. It sits a rung below the Metaspeed Sky racers, so think of it as a carbon tempo shoe and part-time marathon shoe rather than an out-and-out record chaser. At 193g with a 37mm heel and a 7mm drop, it is light and low-slung enough to feel fast, and the FF Turbo foam gives it genuine bounce when you lean into a session. What makes it worth a look is versatility. It will pace a threshold workout on Tuesday, then carry you through a half or a first marathon on Sunday without feeling like overkill. It is not the softest or the most aggressive shoe in its class, but as a one-shoe answer for a runner who wants some carbon assistance across a range of paces, we rate it highly.

Puma cut the Deviate Nitro 4's RRP to £150, £10 under version 3, and made it a friendlier shoe while it was at it. Reviewers agree it's the best-fitting Deviate so far: the upper has more give, and the midsole feels softer on easy runs yet still picks up when you push. Think of it as a carbon-plated daily training shoe and tempo shoe rather than a marathon racer. It sits lower than most super trainers, and on paper its 7mm drop is lower than the old model's too. What it lacks is a bit of excitement. One UK review panel liked it but felt rivals such as the Adizero EVO SL are springier, and lab testing found the heel much less lively than the forefoot. We rate it a very good all-rounder, a step behind the best in its class.