Cielo X1 3 vs SC Elite 4

The Hoka Cielo X1 3 is a max-stack carbon racing shoe built for runners who want a big, protective ride without giving up pop at pace. It sits right at the top of the stack rules with a 44mm heel, a carbon plate and a PEBA-based super foam, so it is squarely a marathon and half-marathon shoe rather than a short, snappy 5k racer. The story of this third version is refinement. Earlier Cielo X1 models were brilliant fun but heavy and a handful at slow speeds. This one is billed as the lightest and most stable yet, and that matters because it makes the big platform far easier to actually race in. If you have looked at the Nike Alphafly 3 and wanted something with a broader, more planted feel underfoot, this is the Hoka answer. It is premium at 250 pounds, but for long-distance race day it delivers a genuinely propulsive, cushioned ride.

The New Balance SC Elite 4 is a full-fat carbon marathon racer, and it wears that brief proudly. This is a tall, soft, aggressively cushioned racing shoe built to keep your legs alive deep into the back half of a marathon rather than to feel featherlight off the line. At 237g it is on the heavier side for a carbon racing shoe, so it does not have the darty, snappy feel of a lighter racer like the Nike Vaporfly 4. What you get instead is a big, forgiving platform and a rolling, momentum-holding ride once you are up to pace. With a 4mm drop and a full carbon plate it sits firmly in the marathon-and-half super-shoe class. At £280 RRP it is a premium buy, but for a runner who wants cushioning and protection over knife-edge sharpness, it is one of the more comfortable ways to race a long road event.