Mach 6 vs Deviate Nitro 4

The Hoka Mach 6 is one of the best value do-it-all trainers going, a lightweight road shoe that punches well above its £140 price. It sits in that useful middle ground between a soft daily trainer and a firm racer, so it can handle your easy miles in the week and still come alive when you pick up the pace on tempo day. At 232g with a 5mm drop it feels quick and unfussy underfoot, and the bouncy supercritical foam gives you a lively toe-off without the harshness of a plated racing shoe. There is no carbon plate here, which keeps the ride natural and forgiving. We rate it as a genuine one-shoe solution for runners who want a single pair for most of their training. If you are chasing a marathon PB you will want a plated shoe on race day, but for everything in the build up the Mach 6 is hard to beat. The Mach 7 refines the formula, though the 6 is often the smarter buy on price.

Puma cut the Deviate Nitro 4's RRP to £150, £10 under version 3, and made it a friendlier shoe while it was at it. Reviewers agree it's the best-fitting Deviate so far: the upper has more give, and the midsole feels softer on easy runs yet still picks up when you push. Think of it as a carbon-plated daily training shoe and tempo shoe rather than a marathon racer. It sits lower than most super trainers, and on paper its 7mm drop is lower than the old model's too. What it lacks is a bit of excitement. One UK review panel liked it but felt rivals such as the Adizero EVO SL are springier, and lab testing found the heel much less lively than the forefoot. We rate it a very good all-rounder, a step behind the best in its class.